David is a scientist not a politician and much of his work has been about identifying the harms associated with various drugs and other activities. His research shows that most illegal drugs are less harmful than legal drugs and other activities. The fact that horse riding is more dangerous than taking ecstasy and smoking cannabis is far less likely to kill you than wine or beer is an inconvenient truth for a government that whilst supporting the alcohol industry promotes the criminalisation of less harmful drugs on the basis of risk. The chart below produced by Nutt compares the harmfulness of legal and illegal drugs:
This shows clearly that the claim that drug classification is anything to with harm is nonsense.
Despite having demonstrated the nonsense of drug policy Nutt was appointed as Chair of the Advisory Committee on the Misuse of Drugs (ACMD) effectively making the Government's chief advisor on drug policy. Not surprisingly Nutt tried to advise the Government to move towards an evidence based policy and to sort out the mess of the classification system. This was too much for Home Secretary Alan Johnson who following the publication of the Eve Saville Lecture last week sacked Nutt.
Much though I respect David Nutt I thought he was wrong as the classification system needs abolishing not reforming. This case has been made powerfully by Steve Rolles in an article The ABC of UK drug classification - not fit for purpose (pages 7-9). Essentially classification links criminal sanctions to 'harmfulness'. This presumes that criminal justice is the most appropriate method for managing drugs potential harm. This approach has clearly failed with drug use increasing, availability widening, and price falling since it was introduced. It has also seen incentives on producers to produce stronger products and dealers to mix all sort of (often dangerous) rubbish with the product.
I suspect that although Nutt was an irritant to Government whilst he was an advisor, insisting on telling them truths they really didn't want to hear he will be a more substantial critic now he has been sacked. Freed from the ACMD and its role in the classification system he will now be able to look at wider drug policy and use his expertise to critique drug policy in far more detail. His sacking is likely to prove a massive mistake for government.
FURTHER UPDATE there is a petition which can be signed up to on the Prime Minister's web site - you can sign it here
It says:
We the undersigned petition the Prime Minister to Re-instate Professor David Nutt On 30 October 2009 the Home Secretary sacked the Chair of the Advisory Council on the Misuse of Drugs. Professor Nutt has expressed politically unpopular opinions such as -
Alcohol ranks as the fifth most harmful drug after heroin, cocaine, barbiturates and methadone. Tobacco is ranked ninth"
and
Cannabis, LSD and ecstasy, while harmful, are ranked lower at 11, 14 and 18 respectively."
Drug policy should be based on science not hysteria. Scientists expressing their honestly held expert opinions should not find themselves in fear of losing their jobs.
Who’s Not Cool With AC?
-
This past summer was hot, hotter than it used to be, and this is causing a
lot of new challenges for work, infrastructure, our social lives, and our
health...
STEPHEN SINCLAIR WASHINGTON DOC
-
*ARTICLE BY JIM BRUNNER SEATTLE TIMES*
Washington prisons chief Stephen Sinclair was forced out of his job by Gov.
Inslee, records show By Jim Brunner...
Films of the Year 2019
-
For the seventeenth consecutive year, this is my annual list of films I've
watched over the last 12 months. As ever, this means actual visits to the
cinem...
Increase Your Productivity as a Working Parent
-
This is a sample intro paragraph and can be used to introduce readers to
your article. This is an example of a WordPress post, you could edit this
to put i...
5 of the best personal finance books out there
-
My name is Ema and I’m a self-confessed book-a-holic. Phew! It feels good
to get that off my chest. I absolutely love reading and more often than
not, read...
Marooned and toasted cheese
-
That’s how I feel right now. Marooned. Ironic for a Ben Gunn….
For much of my time in prison I had the luxury of a stable, foundational
set of ideas and ...
This blog has moved!
-
This blog now updates at http://www.penny-red.com/.
It's been a fun four years at blogspot, but the new site is much shinier.
Update your bookmarks! :)
STOKES CROFT: FREE SHOP
-
Having faced an eviction and then having sitex plastered all over the
front of it, the communities freeshop has been given a revamp! The ethos of
the free...
Moving home
-
Almost three years ago I welcomed readers to this space with these words:
"What the world really needs is another blog. With only 175,000 created
every day...
Thought of the Day
-
" There was a proposition in a township there to discontinue public schools
because they were too expensive. An old farmer spoke up and said if they
stoppe...
Home Page
-
*OBJECT challenges ‘sex object culture’ – the normalising of the porn and
sex industry through lap dancing clubs, Page 3 and sexist ads.* OBJECT is
an aw...
No comments:
Post a Comment